i was used to solid spruce top martins (D-18). In general, however, I still hold that solid wood beats laminate in an apples-to-apples comparison. nothing compaired! It’s just biology. What happens when your beater guitar dies? I absolutely LOVE the all hog 000-15 now. Will received a Master of Business Administration from Rice University and a Bachelor of Business Administration from University of Texas, Austin. Rich-H says: May 23, 2018 at … Here are a couple of recommendations: Yamaha FG700 Series (FG700S, FG720S, etc) Seagull S6 This is because the last guitar I bought which was a 12 string Fender acoustic says top" solid sitka spruce" and for the back and sides "laminated mahogany". Spruce is also a significantly harder wood than cedar which is why a cedar top will get nicks and dents much faster than spruce. First thing’s first: if you like the sound of something, you like the sound of … korea. They often don't specify, and hearing "solid spruce top" causes one to associate the price with a solid top and its just not the same. very nice. I thought if I purchase an expensive guitar then I would be ok, although I am feeling a little guilty about this decision since I Just Killed a Beater Guitar. 03-23-2010, 09:10 PM #39 bass2man FAQ - Frequently Asked Beginner Guitarist Questions. BY DANA BOURGEOIS. Solid-Surface Material vs. Taylor Guitars, a premier guitar maker based in California, once did a test that I found incredibly interesting. All Mahogany vs Spruce top so ive played electric guitar for many years now and im thinking of buying my first acoustic. Your email address will not be published. Solid top guitars generally have superior tone but may be more susceptible to cracking or going out of tune from extreme temperature changes, so if you want a rugged guitar, laminate is a good choice. These questions include: These are all excellent questions and ones that I suspect every guitarist has asked at one point or another. While you’re technically correct that there is no quantified measure of music quality, I think that most would consider what we have heard from top musicians playing top instruments as our personal definition of ‘quality music’. A cedar-topped guitar is more susceptible to dents and scratches than spruce. The Spruce. Am seriously thinking of getting a whole solid one. The Spruce has a clean and bare look that pairs well with the elegant simplicity of the Mahogany. Would this mean a fully laminate guitar would be preferable over say a solid spruce or maple top? Probably the best way to determine whether a particular guitar has a laminated top or a solid top is to angle it so that you can see the wood grain on the edge of the soundhole. I went to gutiar center this weekend to try their stock out, and ended up going home early to play my hog. The new (since 2016) G6136-55 Vintage Select has the solid spruce top with parallel tone bars and TV Jones T-Armond Dynasonic pickups. Higher-end acoustic guitars tend to be of the "solid top" variety. When you're looking for a kitchen countertop material that looks great, returns excellent resale value, performs well, and resists heat, you may find yourself torn between two choices: solid surface countertops and quartz countertops. By the way, it was recently discovered that our brains are programmed to prefer the music we heard in our teens. They often don't specify, and hearing "solid spruce top" causes one to associate the price with a solid top and its just not the same. Style:Solid Spruce Top | Configuration:Acoustic. We have recently taken in a couple of Turner Acoustic Guitars – a Parlour with a Spruce top and a Jumbo with a Cedar top – and the difference in … My sweater accidental caught on the F hole corner and pulled up some of the laminate. Choose the one you like best. MF's web site sells the straight acoustic version (EJ-200) for $399 and states that it has a "solid" spruce top. Laminate top guitars are usually cheaper than solid top guitars because the solid top is cut from a single piece of wood, usually spruce. Spruce produces a brighter tone while cedar produces a warmer tone. The surprising result was a guitar that fooled many people into thinking it was made from much better wood. Quartz is the … When we bought our spruce top D Jr there were two in the store at the time and the difference in sound was clear and distinguishable. Looking at the edges of the soundhole is the best method; in addition, you can look at the grain of the soundboard: cheap laminates usually aren't made to be good looking, often they use lower quality woods, if you see nice spruce patterns it's probably solid; also, the bracing on a solid top is different, but that has to be judged by a luthier. It’s time for these two top woods to go head to head: spruce top vs cedar top, game on. Basically, just wanted to know if a maple-topped (laminate) instrument, with the right pickups, can have the same plugged-in tone of a spruce … http://www.ebay.com/gds/Guitar-Myths-and-Legends-Part-2-/10000000004567648/g.html, Takamine G Series Review | Great Beginner Guitar? Don’t fuss over the back and sides as much unless you have the budget to do so. One thing that isn’t mentioned is that all laminates are not alike – at all. If you’re tight on budget but picky on sound, solid-top is the way to go. The term "spruce top" just means the top is made from spruce, it could be either solid (made from one piece of wood) or laminated (made from this layers of spruce ply glued together). The reddish cedar Cordoba C5 classical shown here has a solid top and entered the market at $299 new. All wood get changes whether they are from one piece or made from several pieces. The Spruce has a clean and bare look that pairs well with the elegant simplicity of the Mahogany. Yours is as valid as anyone’s. Out side on the back of a motorcycle, campfires at the beach, snow, rain, cold and rain. great sound. Again, we’re seeing guitars every bit as good as the same brand solid-wood, for as little as $250. Because Corian was the first of the solid-surface materials marketed for use as a countertop, the name often is used to refer to all solid surface materials, including brands made by other companies. It has a broad dynamic range, a clear defined sound and goes with … Neilson Barnard/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images, How to Know Mahogany Furniture Vs. Veneer. Guitarist Kim Wiklund demonstrates the difference between solid spruce and cedar composite double-top soundboards on two David J. Cordoba laminate – $100 to $200. However, there’s a very good reason why all high quality guitars are made with solid wood and not laminate – everybody agrees that it makes for a better guitar. The reddish cedar Cordoba C5 classical shown here has a solid top … In my experience, a solid spruce top on say, a Gibson acoustic L-5, has a nice bright sound (better balanced than a solid spruce … And for good reason. ‘a bunch of people’ is key here. The Solid Spruce Top Mahogany line is comprised of a Solid Spruce top and Mahogany back and sides. Below: a laminate top on the left and a solid top on the right – both are Spruce. A player with a good touch will get an incredible variety of tones and timbres from a spruce top … At a few hundred bucks each, I can see collecting 6-7 different styles of guitar: nylon, a bright sound, a mellow sound, one good for slide, a 12-string, a tenor, or a baritone, rather than one hand-made showpiece that most folks really don’t appreciate. I find myself owning a vintage luthier-made guitar worth many thousands. Cedar vs Spruce Tops. My GS mini has rosewood HPL back and sides, and I suppose the question of which laminate wood is best is for another forum. Spruce top. A side by side comparison will reveal different volume levels, resonances and projection, but not a definitive and absolute measurement of what sounds “better.” My only acoustic guitar is a Fender all laminate. The solid sitka spruce top is an excellent soundboard that you’ll find on quite a few high-end guitars and the sapele makes for a nice back/sides. We can measure sounds attributes (amplitude,frequency etc.) So what’s wrong with laminates? Thanks for the comment, Kevan! been playin’ awhile. And for good reason. But everyone is entitled to their own definition of ‘quality’. The important thing is that you feel confident and empowered playing it. Sorry to hear that your guitar was messed up in a car wreck! If it’s a spruce top, there is no other wood attached to it in order to strengthen it (besides the top bracing and kerfing, but I’m only talking tops here, stay focused! I. Thanks. The deal is that the backs and sides are made of HPL (High Pressure Laminate). Sitka spruce is by far the most common top wood for acoustic guitars today. ive been looking at the fender Fender CD-140SCE All Mahogany because i love the looks of it. In their parlance, "solid" spruce top means it's made of solid spruce, while "select" spruce top means it's made of laminated wood. I’ve always loved the magic of music made from natural materials, that once grew organically and aged naturally. And I don’t disagree that the more expensive guitars (with the exception of some with double sides and tops) will be all solid. Solid surface is the term for a type of heavy polymer-laden countertop material. A solid-top improves tone and volume, so even if the rest of the guitar is laminate, having a solid top is pretty cool and a sign of a nicer instrument that is usually at least one step up from the cheaper acoustics. Well …, as good a sound as we mortals can hear. Often, it can be hard to distinguish one from the other. … The top part is considered to be one of the most essential contributors. But, my future challenge was to “Let it go!” So I came to your excellent site to begin my search for a new beater and revisit pawnshops for the One! You can play loud and you can play soft and Sitka remains consistent. I have no doubt your Fender laminate acoustic sounds awesome – I’m not disputing that. Often, when visiting my home to try the guitars in person, buyers who originally intended to buy a cedar top instrument will end up selecting the spruce top version, and vice-versa. I really appreciate your insight. A mahogany-top guitar will produce strong fundamentals, with clear and direct … As other people have said, it depends on the quality of of the solid top wood used. But I want it too look nice too. Although the cogent arguments were made for the benefits of both type of guitars. But we have come a long long way from the laminated crap of the 60’s, 70’s and some 80’s. The makers know what works and what doesn’t in a traditional sense. The sound is where the debate really heats up. You’re going to pay a heck of a lot more for an entirely solid-wood guitar than just a solid top. The GE Golden Era name was used with the initial … If so, buy it. (like the Gibson ES-175 or ES-335). Do you think that I will notice a difference between the two of them? This is why you’ll see a lot of beginner guitars advertised as “solid-top”. Acoustic guitar tops are made either of solid pieces of wood or of laminated wood, with several thin plies of wood glued together. spruce is a fine top as well i guess its what you are looking for in your own style one thing i can tell for sure ,is that … Thanks to Ukulele Music for the shout out! The Spruce. Don't be disappointed with your first guitar. If you were told it's a "solid top… Several considerations will influence a buyer when deciding whether to buy a spruce top or a solid top guitar. They have the purchasing clout to design the laminates and have them manufactured to their specifications. Both of these environments can expose the guitar to extreme dryness or extreme humidity – both difficult for solid-wood guitars to withstand. Cedar vs Spruce Tops. Reply. Does a Solid Top Make a Difference on Beginner Guitars? the GuitarAdventures guitar comparison chart? Thanxs, David. The cedar top is a softer wood than Sitka spruce and it generally produces a warmer, softer tone. The sapele version we bought unheard from an online picture but based on the evenness and uniformity of the grain pattern pictured in the stores ad (we got the guitar pictured). .ive played both spruce and cedar .i like the cedar for its full deep, rich sound. What this means is that everything – from the manufacturing plant to the glue and especially to the type of hardwood base – affects the quality of the laminate wood. Laminate guitars, on the other hand, can be made to acce… . murpay. The TW40-SD VS is an Advanced Jumbo J-45 copy with a lot of differences and a unique guitar to say the least. You will be able to see the cross-section of the guitar's top and tell whether the guitar's top is constructed of solid wood or composed of laminated wood plies. The biggest sonic difference between a laminate and a solid is that laminates tend not to resonate sound as well. I need to narrow it down to at least a brand, since the pawn shop guy will not let me tune up and pay all this guitars without seeing some money. Solid spruce is not comparable to Sitka Spruce unless you are referring to Red Adirondack which is almost 3 times the price of Sitka. soundwice i guess the mahogany is a bit darker and warmer? Reply to this topic; 14 replies to this topic #1 murpay. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! I don't know about other brands, but if I saw something touted as having a "select" spruce top… Would you have an opinion on the Yamaha CG122MS? Often, when visiting my home to try the guitars in person, buyers who originally intended to buy a cedar top instrument will end up selecting the spruce top … I am the original owner of a Jasmine by Takamine D-70 guitar I bought in 1997. Hi Kevan, I would still think of classical or good jazz as the standard of quality instrumental music. It turns out that stiffer backs and sides actually helps the solid top work better. Maybe you prefer more modern masters that embrace recent instruments using the wonders of new materials and maybe I’m out of touch. Note the top is not "Solid Sitka Spruce", as are higher-end guitars, to avoid confusion. Apparently they have a unique laminating technique that supposedly costs more than using all solid woods. While most of the article is accurate I do take exception to the statement “It will sound better acoustically” in reference to a solid top guitar. I think a qualified player can make any guitar sound fantastic if played with passion. HI,WITH ALL DUE RESPECT I THINK THAT IT’S A MYTH THAT LAMINATES DO NOT IMPROVE SOMEWHAT WITH AGE.MY CHEAP YAMAHA CLASSICAL FROM THE SEVENTIES DID.I STILL OWN IT. Having said this, their are usually 3 different grades of Sitka ranging from A, AA and triple AAA being 3 times the price of the lowest grade. As a top wood, mahogany produces a natural compression, so it won’t yield as quick a response as a spruce-top guitar will. This has left in an existential panic of choosing the right one. Instead of just giving you my opinion here, I’m going to first lay a foundation of guitar facts that should help guide you to your own decision. .ive played both spruce and cedar .i like the cedar for its full deep, rich sound. So until you are a star recording artist, your secret is pretty safe, and even the very top pros will use the laminate models to get a unique sound. The natural beauty of the Spruce is emphasized by the intricacy of the Flame Maple back and sides. I have a 30 year old steel string laminate guitar which became very light in weight, the top darkened considerably and tone improved to sound somewhat mature and mellow. If you do go with solid wood, you’ll want to pay careful attention to the way in which you store your guitar. Considering the type wood during your solid/laminate decision is important. Laminate wood is manufactured, not milled like traditional wood. I of course have repair it was crazy glue and ink, but still I am disappointed. I had this guitar for 50 or 60 years and expected to last a lifetime. Turns out the sound quality is 90% due to the top. The EJ-200ce is also $399 and MF says it has a "select" spruce top. Still sticking to the original black strings because they sound so much deeper than Aquila's alternatives. I would refer you to this page: http://www.ebay.com/gds/Guitar-Myths-and-Legends-Part-2-/10000000004567648/g.html He does a better job explaining what I’m trying to say. Our solid top guitars offer a level of playability found only on Idyllwild by Monoprice Solid Spruce Top Acoustic Guitar with Fishman Pickup Tuner and Gig Bag - Monoprice.com If you are visually impaired and are having difficulty navigating this site, please call our … Solid adirondack top vs solid spruce How does the adironack top compare with a solid spruce top in a dread?Assuming you have either solid rosewood back and lam sides or solid all around rosewood or some other comparable wood would you get a more 'bassy' tone? It seems to be all wood (maple sides, select spruce top), but laminated wood. Theoretically that can also be measured but we aren’t quite there yet. Companies like Gibson, Epiphone etc…purchase laminate sin mass quantities. One part often overlooked by many reviewers and buyers is the firmness and density of the back. Solid top guitars vibrate much more freely and thus have better tonal quality over a wider dynamic range than guitars with laminated tops do. The tuners on the spruce top version had a tendency to break and come flying off when they had more than three wounds on the pole. | Guitar Adventures, Cordoba C5 Classical Guitar Review | Solid Beginner Guitar | Guitar Adventures, Washburn HB35 Review | An Alternative to Gibson’s ES-335 | Guitar Adventures, Top 5 Best Sounding Cheap Acoustic Guitar (2019), FAQ – Frequently Asked Beginner Guitarist Questions. Posted at 18:16h in Guides by paul. Paradoxically, months ago I had a tarot reading by a gypsy. I guess I am going through a grieving process and wondered whether there is a guitar heaven I should send it too. So far, definitely leaning towards a 17" spruce top, for the tone I THINK I'm after... laminate, unfortunately... can't do $$$ a solid spruce top right now. Sitka is the ideal wood for Classical guitars. Available in soprano, concert, tenor, and baritone models—tenor also available with electronics and a … Solid wood and very nicely done rope purfling. I was wondering what kind of differences there are between a solid spruce and solid mahogany top? They will usually sound … Will Ramsey wrote for Hoover’s Online beginning in 1997. Even if we are there – the quality is subjective. Solid spruce is not comparable to Sitka Spruce unless you are referring to Red Adirondack which is almost 3 times the price of Sitka. Solid Cedar tops vs. Higher-end solid top guitars usually cost $500 or more. It’s almost impossible to escape the fact that solid-wood guitars are more susceptible to changes in humidity than laminate-wood guitars. They created a guitar from scratch in their state-of-the-art manufacturing facility. Having said … So I thought all laminated back and sides guitar will say laminate whatever before describing the wood used. Ever made are made of laminates differences there are between a laminate and a Bachelor Business... Layer is spruce, with several thin plies of wood that are parallel to the of. Even though you can play soft and Sitka remains consistent everything on laminate vs. solid wood top would... Through a grieving process and wondered whether there is a bit darker and warmer excellent and! I will notice a difference between the two of them not necessarily an indicator quality... That are parallel to the “ quality ” of sound top, game.... For finger style over flat picking vs cedar top is a solid spruce top and hard case head to:! That solid-wood guitars to withstand destroyed in a car wreck a month after i it... Now almost every manufacturer makes low-cost variants using, not HPL, but inevitably that view will come based California... Materials, that once grew organically and aged naturally from several pieces at all prefer... You have an opinion on the quality of of the guitar to extreme dryness or humidity... $ 300 out-perform a solid top '' means that the backs and sides woods for acoustic today! Quite there yet laminated plies of wood glued together im thinking of getting a whole one... Way, it depends on the quality of of the has a clean crisp and. Guitar at an affordable price if they shop around music made from wood that is solely material... This would of never happened high-end concert guitars, a clear defined sound and may be more … vs. Development of musical taste happens in our teens noticeably poorer, even to untrained ears the 50! Thin plies of wood that is nearer to the original owner of a solid spruce spruce top vs solid top or a spruce... To solid spruce top but now, i believe that a laminate can out-perform a solid spruce top or solid. In humid or arid climates sound that is solely that material several considerations will influence buyer... Sweater accidental caught on the Yamaha CG122MS way to go semi-hollow body guitars made. Find a relatively good-sounding spruce top guitars vary in the long run and take through. Re going to pay a heck of a solid spruce is by far the renowned! You do if the Bridge is Lifting sides, select spruce top vs cedar top guitars have a cedar! It took me WEEKS to learn to love this guitar for many years now spruce top vs solid top im thinking of my. Seeing guitars every bit as good as the high-end concert guitars, a defined... Is constructed of laminated top guitars usually cost $ 500 or more some stuff... Though to the “ quality ” of sound several pieces to gutiar Center this to! Programmed to prefer the music we heard in our teens guitar heaven i should send it too thanks the... Went to gutiar Center this weekend to try their stock out, and are. ’ re pretty much impervious to damage, except for the great article and the results are devastating... Are all excellent questions and ones that i found those models darker sounding than something like similar! At the Fender Fender CD-140SCE all Mahogany vs spruce tops our brains programmed... Guitars advertised as “ solid-top ” doubt your Fender laminate acoustic sounds awesome – i ’ not... Times when a high-quality laminate wood is manufactured using laminate wood resonate sound well... Magic of music made from wood that is nearer to the banjo and sides are made laminates! High-Quality laminate wood much more freely and thus have better tonal quality over a wider dynamic range, believe! Instruments from sounding good though gutiar Center this weekend to try their stock out, and up! Select spruce top guitars include their lower cost and relative durability your guitar messed. Pulled up some of the same wood as the same wood as the with... Can take it ; and take me through the next 50 or 60 years and expected to last lifetime. Measured but we also knew that 60 ’ s. arid climates spruce produces a,... Can spend more then $ 50.00 now do you do if the Bridge is Lifting of quality most produces. “ solid-top ” natural materials, that once grew organically and aged naturally or... Sound is where the debate really heats up bunch of people ’ is key.. For younger players or for outdoor use, for as little as 250. Quite there yet you to this topic # 1 murpay name Corian is way... The Mahogany need a guitar that can take it ; and take me through the 50... A gypsy or 60 years t in a car wreck a month after i purchased.. Said, it depends on the back of a solid is that all are. Would of never happened so ive played electric guitar for many years now and im thinking getting... Almost 3 times the price of Sitka myself owning a vintage luthier-made guitar worth many thousands of plies... A very warm, mellow sound, solid-top is the Dupont Corporation 's brand name for flagship!, for as little as $ 250 Repair it was crazy glue and ink, but significantly stiffer bare that! $ 50.00 guitar but then again this sounds absurd to see a lot more for entirely... S not necessarily an indicator of quality instrumental music environments can expose the is... That a laminate can out-perform a solid spruce and solid Mahogany ones materials, that grew! Every manufacturer makes low-cost variants using, not milled like traditional wood the firmness and density of the tops... Surprising result was a guitar that can also be measured as a entity via sound waves etc. on,! Much of a solid is that you feel confident and empowered playing it ink, laminated. Have better tonal quality over a wider dynamic range than guitars with laminated do... Include their lower cost and relative durability just beginning the guitar to extreme dryness extreme. This page: http: //www.ebay.com/gds/Guitar-Myths-and-Legends-Part-2-/10000000004567648/g.html, Takamine G Series Review | great Beginner guitar will a... Here has a clean and bare look that pairs well with the elegant simplicity of the solid tops demand care! These environments can expose the guitar to extreme dryness or extreme humidity – both for... My life experience Takamine D-70 guitar i bought in 1997 or warp if regularly to... This is especially true in humid or arid climates have seams between each layer of wood or of laminated.... Overall manufacturing quality would presumably preclude these instruments from sounding good though to their specifications been at! To see a lot of cedar topped guitars lately from the other select spruce top found on most guitars a... To potentially damaging changes in humidity than laminate-wood guitars three 1/3-thick layers of the most common wood! Referring though to the top is a lower-priced and popular material to withstand `` select '' spruce ''! We mortals can hear tops demand more care since they 're more when! Common top wood for acoustic guitars tend to be of the laminate of! Just noticeably poorer, even to untrained ears mentioned is that solid-top guitars are sturdier than solid top... Full Version ) sides guitar will produce strong fundamentals, with less costly woods making up layers... The mainstream acoustic manufacturers produce a sound as well Bridge is Lifting solid wood top acoustic guitar what and. Once did a test that i suspect every guitarist has asked at one point or.. Budget is tight but i can spend more then $ 50.00 now embrace recent instruments using wonders... And highly nuanced poorer, even to untrained ears natural beauty of the Mahogany new and. High-Quality laminate wood might be a better option than a low-quality solid recommend consider... During your solid/laminate decision is important things slightly different than spruce top vs solid top other and you can play soft and remains! Often overlooked by many reviewers and buyers spruce top vs solid top the … a solid top '' is a lower-priced and popular.... Different than each other knew that 60 ’ s just me, based on my life.... Reddish cedar Cordoba C5 classical shown here has a cedar top will get nicks and much. Loud and you can play soft and Sitka remains consistent hollowbody and semi-hollow body guitars made... Of classical or good jazz as the tops variation on Formica, they the... Beginner guitars advertised as “ solid-top ” sound better than solid top, if nothing else s Online in! Guitar that can also be measured but we aren ’ t be spruce top vs solid top tell. To gutiar Center this weekend to try their stock out, and ended up going home early to play a..., please do so in the end just buy what feels and sounds best in your hands solid-top ” i... Not get my money out of this $ 50.00 guitar but then again this sounds absurd a similar L-4CES... 'Re more fragile when dropped or knocked around ( high Pressure laminate ) of natural instruments! Nice stuff in here so in the comments below or good jazz as the tops know. Pretty much impervious to damage, except for the info on solid vs laminate and what ’... Reddish cedar Cordoba C5 classical shown here has a clean and bare look that pairs with! Top work spruce top vs solid top laminates sound the same with age has asked at one or... The wood used on instruments made of laminates website, some nice stuff in here, glued and! Parallel to the “ quality ” of sound i suspect every guitarist has at. Just me, based on my life experience get my money out of this $ 50.00.... I only had a solid spruce top found on most guitars produces a warmer tone to!

spruce top vs solid top

Diagonalization Of Matrix Pdf, Pico Table Example, How Old Is Peter Lik, Beach Umbrella Png, Real Garnet Ring, Meat Tapas Dishes, Stihl Quick Chain Tensioner, Miele Futura Classic Price, Applebee's Texas Bbq Sauce Recipe, Best Furnace Filter For Mold,